Retailers speak up: Are politics good (or bad) for business?

We asked 11 retailers to weigh in.
Publish date:

Politics was a big theme for 2017—in our country and in our industry. So many outdoor gear companies stepped up to take very public political stances around public lands. In some cases, it makes the cash register ring. But there are lots of customers out there who want gear companies and gear shops to stick to selling gear, and leave the politics to politicians. 

So, we want to know: When brands get political, does it helps or hurts your business?

We spoke with 11 specialty retail shop owners around the country to hear about their experiences.

Emily White, Co-founder and co-owner of Roads Rivers and Trails in Milford, OH

Emily White of Roads Rivers and Trails

Emily White of Roads Rivers and Trails

Being political helps. Being part of a greater conversation will always be better than avoiding the conversation. People respond to passion and values, they want a genuine relationship. When vendors or retailers take a political stance, it resonates with those who agree, but also becomes an educational force for those who may not. We too took a political stance this year around Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante, and this is what we know: Sales were up. Positive feedback out-numbered negative feedback 50 to 1. Negative feedback was only from those who had never been customers. This, despite us being located in a red county (over 70 percent of the 2016 presidential vote went to Trump).

Terry Lee, CEO of Gear Coop in Costa Mesa, CA

Terry Lee, founder of Gear Coop rock climbing, roped up leaning against a rock wall in green T-shirt

Terry Lee of Gear Coop

I think it's great that companies are taking a stand for what they believe in, and it has not helped or hurt our business. However, it is a shame how polarized the conversation is. Neither side is listening to the other. I think the extremely polarizing politics of today sets a poor example for our children on positive behavior and common decency. It breeds anger, mistrust and hatred. We are better than this. And, we need people to stand up for what we Americans have in common, and work with empathy and compromise where we disagree.

Todd Frank, Owner of The Trailhead in Missoula, MT

Todd Frank of The Trailhead

Todd Frank of The Trailhead

Trump won Montana by 20.5 percent margin, nearly the biggest in the history of Montana presidential elections. One might think in a state so red, brands making a statement about how the administration has treated public lands would hurt our business. But compared to the incredibly predatory tactics employed by all of the vendors’ direct-to-consumer channels, the position brands take on politics has little to do with the success or failure of The Trailhead. Our core customers hate what is happening and appreciate vendors’ positions, which in the end strengthens the relationship between the consumer and the vendor, not between the consumer and the retail shops who support the vendors. The retailer is twisting in the wind, with only a single leading retailer (Patagonia) making any attempt to close the circle with wholesale dealers. The rest are simply attempting to remove the middle man from the relationship.

Brendan Madigan, Owner of Alpenglow Sports in Tahoe City, CA

Brendan Madigan. Long haired smiling man in black hoodie standing in a retail shop

Brendan Madigan of Alpenglow Sports

Regardless of the impact on my business, taking political stances on issues that effect our industry is just the flat-out right thing for brands to do. Too often we place an exorbitant amount emphasis on the bottom line. It's safe to say the majority of the outdoor tribe has been in some way defined by mountain pursuits, and to not fight for public land would be morally reprehensible. I think retailers have an obligation to activate on political and environmental fronts within their communities. Larger companies with deeper pockets have an obligation to fight the good fight on a national level. If your business fights for what it believes in, the sales will always come holistically. And if they don't and you fail, at least you did it by living by what you believe in.

Betsy Bertram, Marketing manager of Townsend Bertram & Company

Betsy Bertram in a black Arc'teryx rain jacket out on the trail

Betsy Bertram of Townsend Bertram & Company

Brands taking a political stance has helped our business. We see it less as brands taking a political stance and more as brands standing up for the planet. When brands advocate for public lands, conservation initiatives, and sustainable business practices, it educates people about what it means to be a conscious consumer and gives credibility to locally owned adventure outfitters like Townsend Bertram & Company as trusted retailers making a positive impact. 

Wes Allen, Owner of Sunlight Sports in Cody, WY

Wes Allen | Black and white headshot against wood

Wes Allen of Sunlight Sports

It's extremely complicated. Brands can make impacts, and there are fights worth fighting. But we see danger, too. Public lands protections should be a slam dunk, but the rhetoric got divisive, strident, and too focused on Bear’s Ears when the issues are so much bigger. That one hurt our business with Patagonia because we have a lot of customers and friends who reacted negatively to how that came across. So, are we going to play to “the base” or build bridges with our stances? We need to be very careful.

Dave Polivy, Founder & owner of Tahoe Mountain Sports in Truckee, CA

Dave Polivy of Tahoe Mountain Sports

Dave Polivy of Tahoe Mountain Sports

I don't think it affects my individual business if a brand takes a stand, but I will say that Patagonia sales have been slowly increasing for us. I can't directly connect that to their political stances, but I suspect it is. I do think brands should be taking political stances on policies that affect their user base because as a business, they can bring a loud, powerful voice to issues. I would like to see more brands actually stand for something, anything, other than just sales and marketing.

Dana Davis, Co-owner of Summit Hut in Tucson, AZ

Dana Davis of Summit Hut

Dana Davis of Summit Hut

Tucson customers have yet to acknowledge a shift in vendors taking public political stances and I have not seen a correlation to an increase or decrease in sales. Summit Hut tries to be very inclusive and is somewhat “quiet” on voicing political opinions. Arizona is a “red” state while Tucson leans “blue”, located an hour from the Mexican border, surrounded by various tribal lands and active mining communities; strong, outspoken political stances can be tricky at best, devastating to one’s bottom-line at worst. Vendors communicating their point of view helps Summit Hut indirectly support shared views while not deviating from our neutral culture.

Ed McAlister, President of River Sports Outfitters in TN

Ed McCalister of River Sports Outfitters

Ed McAlister of River Sports Outfitters

Neither.These issues do not come up on the sales floor, nor should they. For me, they only come up in conversation with people within the industry. I’m sure public lands issues are on the radar for some of our customers, but it’s not a floor topic. And I hope it doesn’t become one.

Ben Rockis, Owner of Backcountry Experience in Durango, CO

Ben Rockis of Backcountry Experience

Ben Rockis of Backcountry Experience

Anything dealing with a political stance is a challenging question. It’s never right nor wrong but rather a discussion. I believe that bringing knowledge or awareness to public lands issues will increase the usage of them—for better or worse—and therefore increase business. Especially for a service, knowledge-oriented retail business. However, if brands take a political stance, they have a responsibility to educate the public correctly on the issue and not grandstand on emotions.

Mike Donohue, Co-owner of Outdoor Gear Exchange in Burlington, VT

Mike Donohue, Outdoor Gear Exchange

Mike Donohue of Outdoor Gear Exchange

When we take a political stance, we do so because we feel the issue is core to our business. All outdoor businesses should be involved with supporting the conservation of wild places and creation of outdoor spaces. We also need to support the nonprofits working for these and other environmental causes. While there may be some marketing benefits for doing so, more importantly, it protects the places we play and the landscapes that inspire us. Joining the Conservation Alliance is a great way to start.


Grassroots Outdoor Alliance Awards

Congrats to the 2019 Grassroots Outdoor Alliance award nominees

Today Grassroots Outdoor Alliance announced the roster of finalists for its 2019 awards, which celebrate the very best in specialty outdoor retail. The winners will be crowned at the group’s Connect buying show on Saturday, June 8, 2019, in Knoxville, Tennessee. Awards are given more

Grassroots Outdoor Alliance Awards

Retailer of the Year, Vendor of the Year, and more

Hundreds of representatives from outdoor brands and retailers gathered last night for the Grassroots Outdoor Alliance annual awards, which pay tribute to the vendors and retailers that are leading the outdoor industry in excellence. The presentation happened in Knoxville, more

Mike Leffler

Retailers at Grassroots Connect speak up about struggles

The black-curtained maze at Grassroots Connect is swarming with like-minded independent specialty retailers placing orders, talking shop, sharing ideas and, yes, commiserating about the challenges they face every day in their businesses. This group of retailers, all members of more

crowd of people gathered at registration desk of Grassroots Connect show

What you missed at Grassroots Outdoor Alliance Connect Show

Grassroots Outdoor Alliance Connect show went down as planned over the weekend, despite the cancellation of Outdoor Retailer Winter Market, which was to be held in the days following Connect. Connect is a critical microcosm and bellwether of the outdoor industry, and SNEWS was more

Sunlight Sports

The best of the best

A Grassroots Outdoor Alliance award is a very big deal. The group, which is a consortium of 64 independent outdoor specialty retailers and 68 vendor partners, represents the best of specialty retail. The awards, which will be given out on June 13, 2018 on night one of the more

a colorful wall of backpacks at Backcountry Experience

How climate change is impacting outdoor shops

Last year a Congressional report confirmed what many within the outdoor industry already knew: climate change will transform the way we do business. The report projected that unless serious action is taken to curb global warming, the U.S. economy could shrink by nearly 10 percent more

Dave Polivy helps fit boots at Tahoe Mountain Sports

New column Retail Voice spotlights retailers in the trenches

When the venerable Denali closed its doors in July 2019, leadership’s reason was that they “could not find a responsible path forward.” It got me wondering, what does it mean to be a responsible retailer today? To be successful, outdoor specialty shops have to offer much more more

interior of outdoor retail store with large green and gray tenr in foreground. Sunlight Sports wins retailer of the year at Grassroots Connect Show 2018

10 coronavirus crisis tips for independent retailers

As the country quickly shuts down in an unprecedented way, many big outdoor retailers like Patagonia, all VF brands, and REI are following suit. Most retailers who operate an online business, as well as brands that operate direct-to-consumer, are still selling product and more

The inside of Townsend Bertram & Company

Retail in the midst of a renaissance

Malcom Daly has been a self-described “floor warrior” at Neptune Mountaineering, in Boulder, Colorado, for years. And sometime back in January, he watched as an older couple—obviously old-school outdoor, in a hobnailboots sort of way—walked into the shop shortly after it more