Trump's first 100 days, according to the outdoor industry

Trump's first 100 days, according to the outdoor industry
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Six industry insiders weigh in on Trump's performance on public lands, climate change, outdoor recreation, and the economy.

So is America great again yet? It may be early on, but the first 100 days in office have been an important benchmark for judging a president’s performance ever since the days of Franklin D. Roosevelt. In that spirit, we asked six panelists from across the outdoor industry to assess President Trump’s progress on four issues dearest to our hearts—and bottom lines.

Meet the panel

Michael Bennet, senator (D-CO)
Blake Henning, chief conservation officer of the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation
Brian Linton, founder and CEO of United by Blue
Jon Snyder, policy advisor for outdoor recreation and economic development to Washington governor Jay Inslee
John Sterling, executive director of the Conservation Alliance
Jessica Wahl, government affairs manager at Outdoor Industry Association

Issue #1: Public lands

Initially, most of our panelists delivered cautious praise for Trump’s actions concerning our favorite playgrounds: Both he and Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke have said they oppose transferring federal lands to the states and that they want to prioritize fixing a backlog of infrastructure problems. But all that changed on Wednesday, when Trump signed an executive order telling the Department of the Interior to review the designations of a number of existing national monuments created under the 1906 Antiquities Act. Most panelists spoke out strongly against the order, which could potentially roll back federal protections for a number of national monuments.

 Jon Snyder, policy advisor for outdoor recreation and economic development to Washington governor Jay Inslee // Photo: Heidi Arbogast

Jon Snyder, policy advisor for outdoor recreation and economic development to Washington governor Jay Inslee // Photo: Heidi Arbogast

“The President's action is an affront to our communities and tribes that have spent years working to protect areas of cultural and historic significance,” Senator Bennet said in a statement released this week. “It is also an infringement on our rural communities, which rely on national monuments and other public lands to support their outdoor recreation economy.” Added Snyder, “I know no one in our state advocating for national monument review.”

Others pointed out that while it is troubling, the executive order hasn’t actually removed any protections—yet. “Though the order calls for a review, and not actual boundary changes, it’s still an unprecedented move,” Sterling said. “Until now, presidents have left their predecessors’ monuments alone. This sets in motion the real possibility that Trump might shrink monuments that we thought were protected permanently.”

Issue #2: Climate change & energy

Across the board, Trump’s actions in this category drew the loudest protests from our panelists. Among their concerns: his executive order rescinding President Obama’s Clean Power Plan, which restricted emissions from coal-burning power plants; appointing Scott Pruitt, who has publicly said carbon dioxide is not a primary cause of climate change, to head the Environmental Protection Agency; cutting funding for climate change research; and embracing coal.

“I’m taken aback by the fact that we can be so naïve when it comes to climate change,” said Linton. “Things like rolling back the Clean Power Plan, things that will allow for more coal consumption without regulation, more drilling and energy exploitation, and the general disregard for the long-term implications of that.”

Wahl agreed. “Decreased restrictions on emissions is not good for air quality or the health of people outside,” she said. “And the move to limit regulations on fracking, the guardrails that have been set up to protect the parks and natural landscapes—that’s a concern.”

Black and white headshot of John Sterling in Protect Owyhee T-shirt

John Sterling, executive director of the Conservation Alliance // Photo: Ben Moon

“The fact that Trump is going to undo the most powerful regulations that Obama put in place is a big step backward,” echoed Sterling. “He has this totally baffling obsession with coal.” And the president’s emphasis on so-called “clean coal” doesn’t impress Sterling, either: “That’s trying to put lipstick on a pig. Everyone knows that coal is the number-one carbon pollution source, and the sooner we can get away from burning it, the better we’ll be.”

The state representatives noted that Trump’s weak stance on climate makes state action all the more critical. “If the leadership in DC isn’t there, it’s important for states to lead on this,” said Snyder, noting that Washington State is acting to limit carbon emissions, expand electric vehicles, and phase out coal power.

“In Colorado, we are committed to combatting climate change, growing our robust outdoor recreation and clean energy economies, and protecting our public lands,” added Bennet. “I will continue to prioritize these issues, despite Washington’s efforts to move us backward.”

The lone bright spot in climate change policy: Trump has not officially withdrawn from the 2015 Paris Agreement. But with all of the president’s rejections of emissions regulation, “It’s only a matter of time before the U.S. will be in breach of it,” said Linton.

Trump's first 100 days, according to the outdoor industry

Blake Henning, chief conservation officer of the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation // Photo: Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation

Issue #3: Outdoor recreation policy

Last year’s passage of the Outdoor REC Act had the industry cheering for its recognition of outdoor recreation’s economic might—but so far, anyway, panelists said we’ve seen little attention from the administration. “There have been no meetings with outdoor recreation executives, no direct outreach,” noted Wahl.

But Henning was more optimistic: “There have been generally promising signs, like numbers coming out in the last few years about how important outdoor recreation is, and how much it contributes to the economy. And we’re positive about [Interior Secretary] Zinke, being a former Montanan and knowing how important that is to his home state.” As Sec. Zinke said this week in the wake of the Antiquities Act executive order, “The Antiquities Act and the monuments that we have protected have done a great service to the public and are some of our most treasured lands in this country…No one loves our public lands more than I.”

But several panelists pointed out how Trump’s proposed budget cuts to federal land management agencies would hurt outdoor recreation. “He’s taken an axe to the budgets of the agencies that manage public lands—20- to 40-percent cuts to the Department of the Interior, the Park Service, and the Forest Service,” said Sterling. “That’s going to diminish the experience of outdoor recreation on those lands.”

 Brian Linton, founder and CEO of United by Blue // Photo: United by Blue

Brian Linton, founder and CEO of United by Blue // Photo: United by Blue

Not to mention the proposed 31-percent cut to the EPA’s budget. “I don’t know if there’s good understanding to how much the EPA benefits the health of our public lands, particularly our public waters,” said Snyder.

The ripple effect of these cuts is what worries Linton: “If we’re not keeping up our parks and bringing in the younger generation and showing them what true wilderness looks like, that’s going to have a trickle-down effect in how we treat things like climate change going forward,” he said.

 Jessica Wahl, government affairs manager at Outdoor Industry Association // Photo: OIA

Jessica Wahl, government affairs manager at Outdoor Industry Association // Photo: OIA

Issue #4: Economy and trade

The president’s actions on trade similarly concerned our panelists—for the OIA’s Wahl, particularly the withdrawal from the Trans-Pacific Partnership. “Withdrawing was a disappointment and a missed opportunity, but it wasn’t a surprise,” said Wahl. “With companies that produce overseas, we’re interested in making sure their tariffs are fair and lower, and enforcing US trade laws to make sure labor and environmental standards are being met.”

“We make product everywhere,” added Linton. “It’s incredibly important to have a global supply chain. To add restrictions or tariffs and restrict the flow of goods across the border, even threatening that, is very dangerous for trade.”

And Snyder pointed out that Trump’s focus on employment is missing out on a key sector of the economy. “I appreciate the emphasis on jobs, but I don’t see an appreciation for the outdoor recreation jobs we have in our state and how they’re connected to climate,” he said, citing the salmon fishing, skiing, and whitewater rafting industries as a few that stand to suffer without climate action.

Trump’s 100-day grades

In short: If the outdoor industry were issuing Trump a report card for his first hundred days, it shows he has serious work to do. Though the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation’s Henning gave him an overall B thus far, some other panelist’s grades bottomed out with Ds and F-pluses. That’s just one more reason for the industry—worth $887 billion in consumer spending, according to an OIA report released this week—to speak up even louder.

Tags
news-type:
Outdoor Industry
terms:
PoliticsEnvironment
industry-type:
Outdoor Industry

Related

Land and Water Conservation Fund

Trump's budget cuts promise to cause headaches for outdoor industry

The victims of budget cuts include the EPA, State Department, climate change work, Interior Department, Land and Water Conservation Fund, and more. If you’ve heard anything yet about President Donald Trump’s budget proposal, you’ve likely heard that it dramatically cuts the ...read more

33443700744_3ca0ff1c3e_z

"A hypocritical move:" Trump signs executive order to review Antiquities Act as industry gathers on Capitol Hill

Capitol Hill is teeming with members of the outdoor industry fighting for public lands this week, yet steps away, President Trump orders Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke to review National Monuments. At the precise moment that 130 members of the outdoor industry were ...read more

Trump_signing_order_January_27

Trump expected to sign order seeking review of recent national monuments

Sen. Tim Kaine is outraged by Trump's move to dismantle national momuments: "The notion that these designations by presidents are wrong makes me furious." President Donald Trump is expected to sign an executive order today seeking a review of national monuments established in ...read more

Harpers Ferry

Trump donates his first quarter salary to the National Park Service

Trump's salary will go toward the backlog of maintenance projects at historic battlefields. The Department of the Interior announced on Monday that President Donald Trump would donate his first quarter salary to the National Park Service. The money will go toward the maintenance ...read more

Trump Energy Independence order

Trump signs order to dismantle Obama's Clean Power Plan

Trump's "Energy Independence" order threatens the environment. President Donald Trump has signed an order intended to undo much of the work his predecessor did regarding climate change. The “Energy Independence” executive order directs the Environmental Protection Agency to ...read more

Donald Trump Keystone

On anniversary of ecological disaster, Trump approves Keystone Pipeline

The project will pump oil for thousands of miles through the United States. Friday morning, the 28th anniversary of the Exxon Valdez oil spill that killed hundreds of thousands of animals and polluted 1,000 miles of Alaska’s coastline, President Donald Trump approved the ...read more

polar-bear-global-warming-june-2017

Trump bails on Paris Accord and outdoor industry reacts

In a move that sent shockwaves through political and environmental circles across the globe, President Trump announced his intention to withdraw the U.S. from the Paris Agreement on Thursday. The decision keeps with Trump’s campaign commitment to end U.S. participation in the ...read more

Patagonia's CEO Rose Marcario Releases Statement on Trump National Monuments Executive Order

Less than 24 hours after joining with our industry to celebrate the economic power of outdoor recreation, in a hypocritical move, the Trump administration took unprecedented steps that could result in the removal of protections for treasured public lands. We take this as a sign ...read more

Bears Ears National Monument

Utah has crashed the Outdoor Retailer bid party

Utah wants in on the Outdoor Retailer bid process, even though it was uninvited. Utah knows it wasn’t invited to the bid party for Outdoor Retailer, but it has submitted an unsolicited proposal anyway, according to Salt Lake City news outlets. "We know political winds can ...read more