Retailers chime in on Supreme Court online sales tax ruling

Some specialty outdoor retailers aren't sure if the decision will help them or hurt them.
Shopping online on cell phone

The Supreme Court ruled that all internet sellers—from big to small—will have to start collecting sales tax from the states they sell in.

Brick-and-mortar retail might have scored a point over mega online retailers stores today, thanks to a new Supreme Court ruling that gives states the authority to require sales tax, even if the sellers don't have a physical location in that state.

But some specialty retailers don’t believe that customers will stop ordering gear from the convenience of their home and start driving to shops to compare low prices.

The decision, in South Dakota v. Wayfair Inc., overturns a 1990s decision meant to help, what was at the time, a relatively small online industry. 

Nearly three decades later, e-commerce is a way of life and serious competition for in-store sales.

It is said to level the playing field for brick-and-mortar retailers who complained that the sales tax—and thus, overall higher total price—puts them at a disadvantage against internet sellers, such as Amazon and Wayfair, a home goods seller.

“The Supreme Court’s ruling is a huge win for the future of specialty outdoor retailers and will help ensure that all retailers compete on a level playing field,” said Amy Roberts, executive director of Outdoor Industry Association (OIA), in a statement. “We are proud to have been a part of the effort that resulted in yesterday's decision."

States also benefit because shoppers in most states are supposed to pay a use tax, equivalent to the sales tax, for purchases made on the Internet. Not many comply.

Retailers respond

John Rounds, owner of Adventure Bound onthefly in Ellicotteville, New York, said he doesn’t think the sales tax ruling will help him and other specialty retailers.

“I’m an optimistic person, but I don’t think that that ruling will positively impact specialty retailers at all because I don’t think the consumer is driven by the tax savings for their purchase,” Rounds said. “I think that they’re driven 100 percent by the incredible one-click convenience of doing business on Amazon as well as the probability that if they’re a Prime member, they’re going to get it in two days and with free shipping. If I take my specialty retailer hat off and I objectively look at Amazon from that perspective, they have a phenomenally efficient website from a consumer experience standpoint. It doesn’t get any easier to hop on there and grab what you want.”

In St. Louis, Missouri, Jason Gray, owner of KAMP, sees two sides to the story.

“On one side, it slightly evens the playing field by making the big companies charge the same tax costs that we are obligated to for the products we sell in store,” Gray said. “This means that there is one less incentive to shop online for lowest-price motivated consumers."

Gray is mostly concerned about the complexities of selling online through Shopify, one of the channels retailers use build a robust wholesale business.

"On the other hand, we are also a small e-commerce business, and it’s unclear if managing those tax vagaries will fall upon us or on our e-commerce platform provider," he said. "It would seem that, at least initially, the bigger sites are probably also better equipped to handle new processing requirements than the little ones (as the original ruling pointed out). That said, it seems at least likely that new legislation will need to follow the overturned ruling, which we can only hope will make whatever comes next easier to navigate.”

At Montana's The Trail Head, Owner Todd Frank says the state is one of four others that don't collect sales tax, so businesses selling online in Montana have had a one-up selling out of state. The imbalance is at the heart of the issue, he said.

"For me, outside all the gyrations of who benefits and who doesn't, it is a simple issue of fair play across all channels," Frank said. "If Amazon, or others can and do ship into markets that have sales tax and they are not paying it, the issue is not just the unfair advantage. It's also the damage to the tax base of the communities, which in turn creates an unfair burden on those left paying the tax."

The downside, he said, is that any small business with an online store competing with the DTC channels, big online players, and Amazon, might be pushed out of the market by having to deal with paying taxes in all districts in the country.

"The big guys will have the volume to pay for the additional costs but once again the little guys get the short end of a big stick," Frank said.

More and more retailers are adopting an Amazon strategy. What's yours?


A bike fixing station inside Onion River Outdoors

Back to life: Onion River Outdoors gets a second chance

At the end of last year, the community of Montpelier, Vermont, was crushed when Onion River Sports turned off the lights after 44 years in business. But behind the walls, something was cooking. Former manager Kip Roberts and his wife, Jen, were in talks about owning a bike shop more

Crazy Mountain Outdoor Company

5 #CoolShops deserving some credit

In recognition of National Small Business Week, we want to acknowledge some of the independent specialty #CoolShops working hard to keep the outdoor industry ticking. From coast to coast, here are five of our favorites from each region in the U.S. Did you see our Instagram series more

Locally and Plum River increases data sharing with new partnership

Picture this: a customer walks into a specialty retail shop, spends an hour chatting with a sales associate to find just the right pair of shoes—then heads out empty-handed to go buy that exact pair online. This frustrating situation has played out in countless retail shops more

Skis and snowboards lined up on a rack at a resort

The golden opportunity for specialty outdoor retailers

From electronics to apparel, dog food to toilet paper, consumers are turning to e-commerce avenues for their convenience and speed. And with product reviews at their fingertips, price comparison capabilities just a click away and two-day shipping that’s often free, why wouldn’t more

Adventure Bound Bitcoin #CoolShop

Will Bitcoin take off among outdoor retailers?

Adventure Bound onthefly Owner John Rounds became the first specialty shop in Ellicotteville, New York, and the first outdoor retailer SNEWS has heard of so far to embrace cryptocurrency as a means of staying alive in the competitive market. “Specialty retail is not easy, and in more

The Trail Head River Sports sales floor

Virtual tour: The Trail Head River Sports opens in Montana

Every type of boat you can think of, Todd Frank is displaying in his new 14,000-square-foot The Trail Head River Sports showroom in Missoula, Montana. Canoes, inflatables, paddle boards, rafts, recreational and touring kayaks—you name it. "We’re at the junction of four major more

Walmart everyday low price sign in toy aisle

Why brands quickly changed their minds about selling on

It’s safe to say American shoppers don’t go to Walmart looking for top-of-the line backpacks, winter expedition apparel, and mountaineering gear. But the big box discounter challenged that assumption with the launch of a premium outdoor store last week. “When’s the last time you more

Jonathan Nielsen headshot, Backcountry CEO

Backcountry's CEO on becoming gear makers, not just sellers

In front of a room of journalists in March, Jonathan Nielsen described himself as really good snowboarder, a frequent mountain biker, and an adequate climber. The audience chuckled and the Backcountry CEO took a pause before spilling his excitement over the company's biggest more

backwoods interior

Vote: What brands support their dealers best?

Earlier this week, we published an opinion piece by Todd Frank, owner of The Trail Head in Missoula, Montana, lambasting Ibex or its treatment of its specialty retail partners. Our readers had a lot to say on the topic. Of course, there are two sides to every story, and we spoke more