Patagonia: Passionately pursuing land conservation or just trying to sell jackets?

Sen. Rob Bishop says Patagonia is lying and calls the PR campaign against the president galling.
Author:
Publish date:

President Trump’s proclamation to cut two national monuments in southeastern Utah was the match that lit a public lands fire and Patagonia’s reaction has been nothing but gasoline.

With the swipe of the president’s pen, the Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears National monuments was slashed by 85 percent (that’s over one million acres). Patagonia was livid, and from lawsuits to bold tweets, it has not been holding back.

The tweet from Patagonia that started the social media feud, the now famous black box saying, “Your President Stole Your Land”, was favorited 86,000 times and retweeted 63,000 times.

“The fact that Patagonia and so many other outdoor industry brands like The North Face and Osprey are standing up so strongly for our irreplaceable lands is powerful, good for business, and just the right thing to do,” says Anna Peterson, president of Conservation Communications.

Founder of Denver’s Feral Mountain Co. Jimmy Funkhouser says stop focusing on the economic arguments for protecting wild lands.

But not everyone is on the Patagonia bandwagon. Politicians are speaking out and customers (existing, potential, or former) are telling Patagonia that they don’t agree with its actions.

Congressman Rob Bishop, the representative for Utah’s First District, told the Washington Examiner that the entire PR campaign against what the president is trying to do in Bears Ears and Grand Staircase is “so galling.” Bishop just got a dismissive public denial from Patagonia founder Yvon Chouinard when he invited him to share his point of view in front of the House Natural Resources Committee.

“Because they are trying to say you can either have preservation or you can have development, you can’t have both. That once again is a lie. I am not saying Patagonia is lying, but they are,” Bishop said.

Owner of Three Saints Outdoors John Drollinger, which is an independent sales representative for Marmot, DPS, and ExOfficio, says Yvon and Patagonia have no voice in the American land debate. “If Yvon loved this land, maybe he’d manufacture in this land,” Drollinger said.

He believes that if Patagonia was manufacturing in the U.S. or buying up land here, it would have a more influential voice with this administration. “I think if Patagonia said, ‘hey, give us back Bears Ears, and we’ll open up a plant in Reno, maybe it’d get somewhere.”

What customers are saying

While there has been an overwhelming amount of support for Patagonia’s swift actions on fighting for this land, many people also feel the company should stick to selling outdoor gear. Among thousands of responses on Twitter, a large number chimed in saying Patagonia should stay out of politics, that its stance was wrong, or accusing the company of using this as a ploy to gain more profits.

Marshall Dvorscak is a Utah resident and owns Moab Gear Trader, just about two hours driving distance from Bears Ears and three from Grand Staircase-Escalante. He says not all of his customers agree with Patagonia, and in fact, many are boycotting the company because of its such vocal stance.

“Some customers have the narrative that Patagonia is just trying to sell more jackets,” Dvorscak says. That sentiment was echoed by the U.S. House Committee on Natural Resource’s twitter page after a tweet went out saying that Patagonia just wants to “sell more products to wealthy elitist urban dwellers from New York to San Francisco.”

Jeff Mobley, manager at Colorado Love Outdoors, which is a short drive from Bears Ears, says the store has seen more traffic since the land was made a national monument. Despite the monument being a huge draw to the store, Mobley says a portion of the customer base is against Patagonia’s actions and opinions on this issue.

“Our community is split and feel so strongly on both sides,” he explains. Some locals believe that leaving the land as a monument robs them of utilizing it in ways that could help their economy.

We want to hear from you. Is Patagonia too political? Vote now to see where the industry stands on this. 

Related

utah protest 6

It’s official: Trump slashes Utah national monuments

“There are no words. It’s heartbreaking,” Ace Kvale, outdoor photographer, told SNEWS as he was leaving the Salt Lake City protest against President Trump’s controversial announcement to downsize both Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante. With much resistance but little ...read more

Ryan Zinke

Patagonia and the Interior Department take their fight to Twitter

It's not what you say, it's how you say it. In this case, it's not what you tweet, but what you retweet than can cause an uproar. From the second President Trump announced he would take Ryan Zinke's advice on slashing the size of two Utah monuments, Patagonia has vocalized plans ...read more

patagonia homepage March 29, 2018

Patagonia calling out "lies"

On Thursday, Patagonia’s homepage slideshow featured pictures of a surfer riding a wave, the new micro puff, a dam, and other colorful scenes. By the end of the day, another, more stark image had been added to the mix. The black screen is back, with a new message this time: “The ...read more

Trump moves forward with DAPL, Keystone XL pipelines.

Best of 2017: Top political stories

What a year in politics! This year in particular, politics and the outdoor industry were so intertwined, the SNEWS team definitely covered our share of controversial stories. Here are the top five: Utah asks Trump to rescind on Bears Ears NM, Patagonia pulls out of Outdoor ...read more

Grand Staircase

Feb. 2: Why Patagonia wants you mark this date

In eight days, more than 2 million acres that was formerly within Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments (before President Trump shrank it) will open up to possible mineral and geothermal leasing. Conservation Lands Foundation, The Wilderness Society and ...read more

Outdoor Industry

Why the OIA just sent a letter to Trump

It’s no secret that some of the proposed changes by the Trump administration are leaving the outdoor industry infuriated. On October 19, the Outdoor Industry Association wrote a letter to the commander in chief calling upon him to protect our nation’s lands. More than 350 ...read more

Bears Ears National Monument

Poll | What's the most effective way to protect America’s public lands?

Yesterday, we reported on President Trump's controversial announcement that he would officially reduce the size of the Bears Ears and Grand Escalante-Staircase national monuments.  Outdoor Industry Association Executive Director offered suggestions for action steps: Write a ...read more

Patagonia CEO

Is Chouinard living in a bubble?

The war of words continues between Patagonia and Rep. Rob Bishop (R-Utah). On Friday, Bishop posted yet another photo spoofing Patagonia’s original black box tweet. This one replaced “Patagonia is Lying” with “Patagonia is Hiding”. The post then links to a letter from Bishop to ...read more

Craters of the Moon National Monument

Zinke to recommend downsizing some monuments

Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke is expected to recommend to President Donald Trump that he should decrease the boundaries of some national monuments. Zinke told the Associated Press Thursday morning that he would not recommend eliminating any monuments, and that none of the land in ...read more