Opinion: No honor in Boy Scouts policy against gays

The decision by the Boy Scouts of America earlier this week to reaffirm its policy denying membership to gay scouts and scout leaders is a setback for the organization and the outdoor industry as a whole.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

The decision by the Boy Scouts of America earlier this week to reaffirm its policy denying membership to gay scouts and scout leaders is a setback for the organization and the outdoor industry as a whole.

At a time when the industry is working hard to involve more youth in the outdoors, one of its most historic and iconic youth organizations is turning away willing members with a policy of exclusion and discrimination.

Not only do these decisions deprive people of a great American outdoor tradition, it sends a dangerous message to the Boy Scouts’ more than million youth that their experience is only a privilege for some. There is no honor in choosing a path rooted in fear, cowardness and ignorance.

The outdoor industry needs to loudly push back against those type of messages. The outdoors and its organizations are for everyone, no matter a person's sexual orientation, religion or color of skin. The beauty of the wilderness is that there are no fences or borders to separate us.

That's why it's extremely disappointing that when SNEWS contacted the Outdoor Industry Association, the supposed champion voice of the outdoors, the organization said it had "no statement" on the matter. Their silence on such a issue is equally as damaging.

While it might be easy for the industry to brush off the Boy Scouts as an outcast — exclusionary decisions such as these tend to lead to the eventual decline of an organization, and Boy Scout membership is declining — like it or not, a majority of Americans associate youth and the outdoors with the organization. Furthermore, this policy aside, the Boy Scouts do a lot of good helping foster future outdoor participants and leaders.

Yes, there are many other, more progressive outdoor youth alternatives, such as Big City Mountaineers and NOLS — and the Girl Scouts of America has had a non-discriminatory policy in place since 1980 — but we can’t just leave the old guy behind on the trail, just because he’s a little slow.

The outdoor industry needs to come together through strong speech, finance and personal outreach to educate and return the Boy Scouts to a respected inclusive voice representing our community. While the organization’s leadership claims it has the support from a majority of its members in this most recent poor decision, we think it miscalculated.

It’s time to get the Boy Scouts on the right trail.

--David Clucas

Related

Gerber Legendary Blades Supports Boy Scouts of America

Portland, OR - Gerber Legendary Blades, a leader in the knife and tool industry for over 70 years, is pleased support the Boy Scouts of America and the regional Cascade Pacific Council of the BSA. With a promotion at the recent SHOT Show in Las Vegas, Nevada, Gerber was able to ...read more

A gold coin bearing the Boy Scouts of America motto

The Boy Scouts declare bankruptcy

The Boy Scouts of America, a fixture in the American tradition of outdoor education for more than a century, filed for bankruptcy this morning in response to the hundreds of sex abuse lawsuits that have forced the 110-year-old organization to the brink of collapse. A change in ...read more

Check_box_icon.jpg

SNEWS Reader Poll: Scouting indicates it’s mostly fun

The Boy Scouts of America marks its 100th anniversary this year (Girl Scouts turn 100 in 2012), so SNEWS® wondered just how much of an influence Scouting had on the lives of our outdoor and fitness industry readers. Just under 84 percent of our readers who responded to the ...read more

BSA_Jamboree10logo.jpg

Outdoor companies build ties to Scouts through historic Jamboree

Many outdoor industry companies can trace their roots to the Boy Scouts, but as SNEWS reported in our summer issue, the relationship between the industry and the Scouts has weakened over time. (Click here to access the SNEWS summer issue online and read the story “The ...read more

Royal_Robbins_BoyScouts.jpg

SNEWS Outdoor Summer 2010 web extras: Scouting memories from industry veterans Skip Yowell and Royal Robbins

In the SNEWS Outdoor summer 2010 magazine, we explored the relationship between the outdoor industry and the Boy Scouts, as the organization celebrates its 100th anniversary, in a special feature titled, “The Disappearing Partnership.” As a special web extra, industry veterans ...read more

Did you hear?... Partnerhip between Leki USA, Mt. Rogers Outfitters, and the Boy Scouts will benefit Damascus, Virginia

A partnerhip between Leki USA, Virginia retailer Mt. Rogers Outfitters, and the Boy Scouts will benefit the town of Damascus, Virginia, as a part of the Trail Days 2002 from May 16-19. Boy Scouts, wearing "Trail Days 2002 Recycle Team" tees, will help take aluminum cans and ...read more

Boy Scouts_Polygiene

Boy Scouts of America® teams up with Polygiene

MALMÖ, Sweden, July 30, 2014 – Today, the Boy Scouts of America® (BSA) announced it will begin offering merchandise featuring the leading odor-free technology, Polygiene AB. The first item to feature the product is the official BSA Cub Scouts® Hooded Fleece Youth Sweatshirt, ...read more

OIA_Logo.jpg

OPINION: OIA wants you to become a citizen lobbyist for the outdoor industry

As outdoor industry leaders gather in Washington, D.C. this week to speak with members of Congress, sponsors of the Outdoor Industry Association's Capitol Summit tell SNEWS why policy matters to them. Today, we hear from Craig Mackey, director of recreation Policy, Outdoor ...read more

polarguard_banner.gif

SNEWS® Live: Wenonah's Cichanowski receives Distinguished Eagle Scout Award

This edition of SNEWS® Live is brought to you by Polarguard SNEWS® Live: Since the turn of the last century, the Boy Scouts of America has been one of the nation's leading organizations for encouraging kids to get outside. The organization recently honored one of the outdoor ...read more