Number Cruncher: How safe are our public lands under President Trump?

Author:
Updated:
Original:

Donald Trump’s party might be bent on selling off public lands, but no need to panic just yet: Even among Republicans, not everyone is behind the movement.

The GOP declared a new platform priority at the Republican National Convention this July: returning public lands to the states. States are required to maintain a balanced budget — even at the cost of selling off public land to the highest bidder, a move that could jeopardize recreation access on a huge scale. It’s little surprise that the threat of privatization has raised concerns within the outdoor industry.

Buhay_privatization

Now, the rise of President-elect Donald Trump and the concurrent Republican takeover of congress has sounded the alarm for thousands of environmentally concerned Americans. Both the National Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and the Sierra Club, both prominent national conservation nonprofits that actively combat efforts to sell off federal land or transfer them to the states, currently sport homepage banners calling upon site visitors to “Protect Our Planet from Trump.”

The response has been massive. The Sierra Club reports 11,000 new monthly donors since the election — that’s more than the number of new donors they brought on between January 1 and Election Day. The NRDC says a post-election teleconference for supporters amassed an audience 20 times its typical size.

“There’s been an exponential increase in online actions, responses to our emails, and financial support for our work,” said NRDC Communications Assistant Kim Morasse.

Ultimately, this is a good thing for environmental nonprofits, says Athan Manuel, the Sierra Club’s lands protection program director. But is there any real cause for alarm?

The outdoor industry can let out a sigh of relief, at least for now: the answer is no. That conclusion is based on new congressional members’ advertised policy priorities and incumbents’ votes on previous measures, like a proposed Senate amendment to allow the transfer of federal lands to state and local governments (S.Amdt.838 to S.Con.Res.11), a proposed House amendment to limit the power of the Antiquities Act to create new National Monuments (H.Amdt.597 to H.R.2822), and a proposed House amendment regarding transferring public lands to private owners (H.Amdt.1370 to H.R.5538). As such, it’s a rough measure but a good indication that the majority vote on privatization on large-scale land transfer simply isn’t there.

 Though individually unobtrusive, oil wells require access roads, and the resulting web alters the landscape along Colorado’s border with New Mexico. The promise of extraction industry profit is one reason many western states are petitioning the federal government to hand over federal lands. // Photo: Courtesy of Grame Churchyard, via Flickr.

Though individually unobtrusive, oil wells require access roads, and the resulting web alters the landscape along Colorado’s border with New Mexico. The promise of extraction industry profit is one reason many western states are petitioning the federal government to hand over federal lands. // Photo: Courtesy of Grame Churchyard, via Flickr.

In truth, things aren’t as bad from a public land or outdoor recreation perspective as some outdoorists have come to believe. The Outdoor Industry Association endorsed a panel of congressional candidates this year, and 77 percent won their races.

“Of all the environmental issues Trump talked about in the campaign, this is one of the few good ones,” said Manuel, adding that Trump voiced his disagreement with state transfer of lands during the primaries and that he promised to ensure access in a Field and Stream interview. And if the President-elect were to change his mind?

“I don’t think there’s much appetite [among congress members] to accelerate the privatization of public lands,” said Manuel. “It’s been a great talking point for politicians…but in terms of actually voting on it, it won’t go very far, even in this Congress.”

OIA’s Jessica Wahl said that’s partly because there are plenty of republicans who value public lands and are actively fighting to keep them public, either because they support hunting, fishing, and other recreational outlets or because they’re an important resource for ranchers and even extractive industries. And Wahl made it clear that OIA is willing to work with communities and politicians on multi-use strategies.

“We’re not asking communities to pick recreation over other industries,” she said. “We need everything; we just need to be smart about it.”

Making thoughtful compromises between conservation and resource utilization may be the key to bringing parties together on the matter in the future. Hate to compromise where the environment is concerned? Keep the Sierra Club and NRDC donations coming. And keep voting.

Tags
news-type:
Outdoor Industry
industry-type:
Outdoor Industry

Related

Obama_and_Shelton_Johnson

Number Cruncher: The greenest presidents

WHEN PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA STEPS OUT OF THE WHITE HOUSE, he’ll be leaving some big shoes to fill. Half a billion-acre shoes, to be exact. Our current POTUS made headlines again last week when he designated the Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument off the ...read more

Circuit, a Portland-based gym, opened in 2005 and how has three locations. The gym offers bouldering as well as yoga classes, summer camps, and birthday parties. Credit: Evan Lovely/Flickr

Number Cruncher: Climbing gyms are on the rise

The number of climbing gyms in the U.S. is clambering upward, having more than doubled in the past decade. In 2015 alone, the U.S. indoor climbing industry saw 10 percent growth, according to data from the Climbing Business Journal, with 40 new gyms bringing the total up to 381 ...read more

A sunrise boat ride at Indian Creek Recreation Area in Woodworth, Louisiana. Photo from Flickr

Number Cruncher: Retail climate depends on location, location location

The American West is outdoor recreation’s cash cow, according to state-by-state data collected by the Outdoor Industry Association and Southwick Associates. The data cover activities like hiking, camping, fishing, hunting, biking, kayaking and climbing as well as purchases of ...read more

13502993_1036574769724138_5260823044619845178_o

Trump vs. Clinton: Who would treat the outdoor industry better?

Conservation is a hot topic for the public land-dependent outdoor industry. Even President Barack Obama’s efforts - more than any other U.S. president in history - aren’t enough, given the rapid pace of development in the U.S., said Kristen Brengel, VP of government affairs at ...read more

Jose Gonzales, founder of Latino Outdoors. Photo courtesy of REI.

Number Cruncher: Hispanics outspend all other groups

The outdoor industry is overwhelmingly white, but white consumers aren’t the biggest spenders. According to OIA’s ConsumerVue research, for example, Latino outdoorists spend about 27 percent more annually than the average outdoor consumer, and Asian and Pacific Islanders spend ...read more

Reese Witherspoon plays Cheryl Strayed, author of bestseller "Wild," in the movie adaptation of the book. Photo courtesy of Fox Searchlight Pictures.

Number Cruncher: The Real Wild Effect

In the years following the release of Cheryl Strayed’s Wild, first as a novel and then as a star-studded Hollywood production about one woman’s journey on the Pacific Crest Trail, the number of PCT hikers quadrupled. Publications from The Wall Street Journal to Mashable suggest ...read more

Mandatory helmet regulation in resort ski schools are getting kids acclimated to helmets early in life – making them more likely to keep the protective headgear as part of their kit as they grow older. Photo by originallittlehellraiser on Flickr.

Number Cruncher: Helmet use at all-time high

Ten years ago, anyone with a plastic hat glimmering in the sunlight faced sneers from lidless skiers. Today, it’s the opposite. About 78 percent of resort skiers and snowboarders wear helmets, according to recent data by the National Ski Areas Association. A good thing, too—the ...read more

In 2007, helicopters drop water and retardant on the Harris fire, near the Mexican border in California, to stop the wildfire from advancing. Andrea Booher/FEMA / Wikimedia Commons

Number Cruncher: Hungry fires leave the USFS budget starving

Blazes are growing more costly – both to forests and to the Forest Service’s checkbook. In 1991, fire suppression consumed only 13 percent of USFS allocations. Last year, it devoured over half—52 percent—for the first time, according to a 2015 USFS analysis. On average, the ...read more

Graphic by Corey Buhay

Number Cruncher: Fitness trackers drive wearable device boom

Wearable device shipments in 2015 rocketed up 171.6 percent over 2014 shipments, according to market intelligence provider International Data Corporation (IDC)’s preliminary Worldwide Quarterly Wearable Device tracker. IDC names two drivers of the enormous growth: the fitness ...read more