The battle between Google and Amazon might actually help small retailers

Google's latest response to competition from Amazon is a potential windfall for small, independent shops.
Google's latest move may be a boon for small retailers. Courtesy Unsplash.

Google's latest move may be a boon for small retailers. Courtesy Unsplash.

"The very first concept to understand is that this all comes down to a brewing war between Google and Amazon."

That's how Mike Massey, founder of the ecommerce platform Locally, described the recent announcement from Google that the tech giant will start listing products from local retailers on Search, Images, Shopping, Maps, Lens, and Google My Business for free.

"This is shot across the bow from one of the largest tech firms in the world to the other," Massey said. 

When it comes to online shopping, Amazon has steadily stolen search traffic from Google for years, Massey explained. More and more, shoppers are beginning and ending their product searches on Amazon, from initial query to final purchase. This is bad news for Google, as the company makes much of its money from ads on product searches run through its various platforms.

"You don't pay for Gmail or Maps or anything like that. Product search is Google's main business. They're trying to address this Amazon problem by encouraging people to start their shopping searches on Google. That's what this new move is about," said Massey.

This is good news—potentially game-changing news—for small retailers.

"This is enormous for small shops," Massey said. "The kind of exposure that retailers are going to get from this is potentially worth tens of thousands of dollars a month."

To understand Google's move from the consumer side, Massey said he tells people to imagine doing a basic search for the word "pizza."

"What comes up at the top of the page? Not the Wikipedia article for pizza, not the names of famous pizza restaurants in New York City, but relevant local information—pizza places near you—that guide you toward a purchase. That’s now what’s happening with retail. Before, if you typed in 'YETI cooler,' you would have gotten mainly ads from companies that have spent a lot of money on them. Now you’re getting links to local retailers. Google is essentially giving away free advertising."

Of course, there are catches. To take advantage of the program, retailers need to have a viable ecommerce operation that can feed data to Google for the listings. And they need to jump through the hoops of setting up a merchant account with Google, a process that can be arcane and time consuming. 

To solve these problems, Locally has partnered with dbaPlatform to offer a set-up service that handles all aspects of syncing in-stock inventory from local retailers with Google. The service costs $49 a month for one location and an additional $39 a month for each location after that.

"What retailers should understand is that, even though this is a battle between two tech giants, small shops are the winners right now," Massy said.

Time will tell whether he's right. Google is steadfastly private about the machinations of its search algorithms, but all available evidence says it's at least highly possible that local retailers will have a real seat at the table when it comes to Google product searches from now on.

For Massey's part—on behalf of Locally and the hundreds of retailers it services—he's a little less skeptical.

"This is a windfall," he said.


Illustration of people kayaking boat resembling Amazon arrow

The Amazon Survival Guide

When Jeff Bezos first launched Amazon way back in 1994, his original vision was to create an online store that offered a wide selection of books at affordable prices. What he actually created: a retail revolution that would fundamentally change the way consumers shop in the 21st more

Amazon logo on a smartphone screen

Amazon myths: Busted

It can feel like more rumors than facts swarm around Amazon, in part because the retailer is notoriously secretive—and that makes it hard to separate truth from speculation. In most news articles that discuss the world’s largest retailer, experts point out, you won’t find any more

blonde woman shopping on amazon on her laptop, which shows a backpack

What's your Amazon strategy?

Successfully producing outdoor gear used to be such a simple endeavor: Make great product, then sell it through retail partners, or directly through a catalog or your own store. These days, the formula has become a lot more complicated. With the option to distribute through a more

Locally and Plum River increases data sharing with new partnership

Picture this: a customer walks into a specialty retail shop, spends an hour chatting with a sales associate to find just the right pair of shoes—then heads out empty-handed to go buy that exact pair online. This frustrating situation has played out in countless retail shops more


State of the industry: Three retailers discuss how the pandemic has hit them

In recent weeks, we've seen a lot of suffering among retailers, as news of closures, furloughs, and layoffs rolls in. We've also seen the best in people—customers banding together to support independent shops, vendors implementing programs to keep their dealers afloat, and brands more

Man holding credit card buying something on a laptop

Ecommerce platform Locally helps retailers through the crisis

With independent retailers closing down across the country, store owners are searching desperately for ways to keep products moving during the coronavirus crisis. Locally, which supports online sales for stores without dedicated ecommerce platforms on their websites, has more

Walmart everyday low price sign in toy aisle

Why brands quickly changed their minds about selling on

It’s safe to say American shoppers don’t go to Walmart looking for top-of-the line backpacks, winter expedition apparel, and mountaineering gear. But the big box discounter challenged that assumption with the launch of a premium outdoor store last week. “When’s the last time you more

Great Outdoor Provisions

The Outdoor Retailer Playbook: Part I

Everyone in this industry knows the problem by now: The rise of online shopping has turned the traditional outdoor marketplace on its head. Consumers now turn to the internet first when they need new gear; brands seize the chance to sell it directly through their own websites or more

Neptune masked cashier and customer

As retailers open up, results are mostly positive, with some confusion over safety

After months of closures that spelled disaster for some and extreme hardship for many others, retailers both small and large have started reopening across the nation as states lift the stay-at-home mandates that have kept them closed. The results so far, according to multiple more