Consumer Reports Survey: More than half of successful dieters lose weight on their own

Survey of 21,000 readers reveals six stay-thin strategies; Tips for healthful meals on a budget

YONKERS, NY — A new survey published in the February issue of Consumer Reports reveals the secrets of successful dieters, many of whom say they lost weight themselves, without the aid of a commercial diet program, medical treatment, book, or diet pills. Their successful do-it-yourself strategies are unveiled along with tips for healthful meals on a budget in a New Year's do-it-yourself guide to diet and fitness at The online hub also includes tips for building a home gym for less than $100 and ratings for fitness equipment such as treadmills, ellipticals, stationary bikes, heart-rate monitors, pedometers, and infomercial fitness machines.
A total of 21,632 readers completed the survey by the Consumer Reports National Research Center, which identified three key groups: the “always thin” (never overweight), “successful losers” (once overweight but now at least 10 percent lighter, and have kept the pounds off for at least three years), and “failed dieters” (overweight and would like to lose, but still close to heaviest weight). The always thin comprised 16% of the sample and successful losers made up an additional 15%. Failed dieters were, sad to say, 42%. The remaining respondents didn't fit into any of these categories.
In the group of “always-thin” respondents, a mere three percent said that they never exercised and ate whatever they wanted. In fact, the eating and exercise habits of this group look surprisingly similar to those of the “successful losers,” encouraging news for would-be dieters who might think that the “always thin” have a genetic edge.
Through statistical analyses, Consumer Reports was able to identify six key behaviors of these two groups whose eating and exercise habits were closely matched. Consumer Reports defines the behaviors that correlate strongly with having a healthy body mass index (BMI), a measure of weight that takes height into account.
1. Watch portions. Carefully controlling portion size at each meal correlated strongly with a lower BMI. Successful losers were especially likely (62%) to report doing this behavior at least five days a week. So did 57% of the always thin, but only 42% of failed dieters.
2. Limit fat. Fifty-three percent of successful losers and 47% of the always thin restricted fat to less than one-third of daily calorie intake five days a week or more, compared with just 35 % of failed dieters.
3. Eat fruits and vegetables. Forty-nine percent of successful losers and the always thin said they ate five or more servings a day at least five days a week, while 38% of failed dieters did so.
4. Choose whole grains over refined. People with lower BMIs consistently opted for whole-wheat breads, cereals, and other grains over refined (white) grains.
5. Eat at home. As the numbers of days per week respondents ate restaurant or take-out meals increased, so did their weight.
6. Exercise, exercise, exercise. Regular vigorous exercise--the type that increases breathing and heart rate for 30 minutes or longer--was strongly linked to a lower BMI.
Although healthful foods often cost more than high-calorie junk food, Consumer Reports unearthed some encouraging exceptions. Two rich sources of nutrients, black beans and eggs, cost mere pennies per serving and less than plain noodles, which supply fewer nutrients. And for the same price as a doughnut, one can buy a serving of broccoli:
Type of Food Serving Size Calories Per Serving Cost Per Serving
Cooked Black Beans: ½ cup 114 7 cents
Hard-boiled egg: one medium 78 9 cents
Cooked noodles: ¾ cup 166 13 cents
Glazed doughnut: 1 medium 239 32 cents
Cooked broccoli: ½ cup 27 33 cents
Chicken breast: 4 oz. 142 50 cents

Consumer Reports invited its nutrition experts, other staff members, and visitors to the Health blog to share tips for putting together healthful meals for less. The ideas poured in and they're all available in the New Year's DIY guide at . Here are a few good ones:
ü Eat Beans: They're inexpensive, versatile, and a great source of protein and fiber.
ü Choose store brands: Also called “private label,” they are often just as good as the name brand and can save you money.
ü Plant a vegetable garden: It requires a little time, but it can have nice payoffs, including exercise.
ü Shop the perimeter: The sections of the supermarket around the outer walls hold the nutrient-rich foods such as fruits, vegetables, lean meats, fish, and low-fat dairy. The inner aisles contain processed and snack foods.
ü Avoid packaged drinks: Instead of buying pricey teas and fruit drinks, brew your own tea and mix in fruit juice.
The full report is available in the February ‘09 issue or online at

© Consumers Union 2008. The material above is intended for legitimate news entities only; it may not be used for commercial or promotional purposes. Consumer Reports® is published by Consumers Union, an expert, independent nonprofit organization whose mission is to work for a fair, just, and safe marketplace for all consumers and to empower consumers to protect themselves. To achieve this mission, we test, inform, and protect. To maintain our independence and impartiality, Consumers Union accepts no outside advertising, no free test samples, and has no agenda other than the interests of consumers. Consumers Union supports itself through the sale of our information products and services, individual contributions, and a few noncommercial grants.


Consumer Reports Index: Consumers More Optimistic as Sentiment, Stress and Trouble Tracker Levels Improve

YONKERS, N.Y. -- Consumers ended 2009 more optimistic than they have been in the past six months as the January Consumer Reports Index shows Sentiment, Stress and Trouble Tracker levels improving. The Consumer Reports Sentiment Index has shown its first meaningful up tick since more

L.L. Bean, Zappos, and Lands' End Standouts in Consumer Reports' Online Clothing Shopping Survey

YONKERS, N.Y.-- L.L. Bean, Zappos, and Lands' End were among the top rated e-tailers in Consumer Reports' survey of more than 25,000 subscribers of their online clothes shopping experiences at 39 online stores.Those retailers, which scored 92, 91, and 89 respectively, tended to more

Consumer Reports: 76 Percent of Consumers Plan to Cut Back on Holiday Spending

YONKERS, N.Y. -- 'Tis the season to tighten the belt on holiday spending for many Americans this year. Over three-quarters (76%) of Americans plan to cut back on spending on traditional holiday expenses such as gifts, travel, entertaining, decorations, charitable giving, holiday more

Consumer Reports Health tests of treadmills and ellipticals produces 14 top machines

YONKERS, NY— After putting 48 machines to the test, Consumer Reports Health lists 14 recommended treadmills and ellipticals for a home workout, including five Best Buy choices which combine performance and value. The report is part of “Get Fit In 2010,” a do-it-yourself Web guide more

Consumer Reports Index: Americans Hunker Down on Spending Now That the Holiday Shopping Binge Subsides

YONKERS, N.Y. -- The recent holiday season showed some hope for a resurgence in the retail sector, but it appears consumers are back in the doldrums and not willing to spend their way out of the recession, according to the February Consumer Reports Index. The Past 30-Day Retail more

Consumer Reports Index Finds Increased Credit Card Woes Help Drive Consumer Sentiment to Lowest Level in the Past Seven Months

YONKERS, N.Y., Sept. 8 -- Americans feel far worse about their financial situation than they have in the past seven months and continue to be pounded by financial woes driven by increased credit card, healthcare and personal loan issues, according to the Consumer Reports Index more

Consumer Reports Poll: Tough Economy Forces 69 Percent of Americans to Change Holiday Traditions

YONKERS, N.Y. -- With money concerns looming, more than two-thirds (69%) of Americans are changing their family's holiday gift-giving traditions this year, according to Consumer Reports latest Holiday Shopping Poll.Among the changes, 37 percent of families are setting a spending more

US Health Club Members Proclaim - 'I Lost It At The Club!' - And Lose Nearly 20 Tons Of Excess Weight

BOSTON, April 26 -- "I Lost It at the Club!," a fitness industry weight loss initiative coordinated by the International Health, Racquet & Sportsclub Association (IHRSA) and sponsored by equipment manufacturer Life Fitness and Hershey's PayDay PRO(TM) Energy Bar, helped more than more


New Consumer Reports fitness equipment reviews will inevitably spark lively debate

Nothing says "Happy New Year" more than the arrival of fitness equipment reviews in the venerable Consumer Reports magazine -- and the ensuing vibrant debate about the pros and cons of the reviews. Of course, Consumer Reports (CR) isn't the only source of reviews that consumers more