Outlast Files Infringement Lawsuit Against Frisby … Again. - SNEWS

Outlast Files Infringement Lawsuit Against Frisby … Again.

Outlast Technologies, Inc., a Boulder, Colorado-based company that makes temperature regulation materials for foams and fabrics, filed patent infringement lawsuit in the Federal District Court of Colorado against Salem, N.C.-based Frisby Technologies, Inc., a thermal management company more commonly known for its ComforTemp brand.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Outlast Technologies, Inc., a Boulder, Colorado-based company that
makes temperature regulation materials for foams and fabrics, filed
patent infringement lawsuit in the Federal District Court of Colorado
against Salem, N.C.-based Frisby Technologies, Inc., a thermal
management company more commonly known for its ComforTemp brand.

In the suit, Outlast alleges Frisby's ComforTemp non-wovens violates
the Outlast U.S. patent No. 5,366,801 for encapsulated phase-change
materials in non-woven fabrics. Both companies develop such
technologies for a wide range of products, including home furnishings,
footwear, and apparel.

As you will recall from years of SNEWS® coverage, Outlast and Frisby
(Nasdaq: FRIZ) inked a deal licensing specific elements of Outlast's
foam technologies for use with ComforTemp in 1998. Outlast got miffed
when Frisby's manufacturing partners began violating that license
agreement, according to Outlast, and Outlast subsequently filed suit.
Earlier this year, the companies settled that lawsuit and reworked the
licensing agreement to be more specific regarding manufacturing
procedures and foam thickness allowances.

What is at issue now has nothing to do with foam, and everything to do
with non-woven materials and Frisby's July introduction of a joint
project between its company and the German-based company Freudenberg.
The new product takes a traditional non-woven polyester batting and
adds ComforTemp to it in, what Frisby calls, "a unique manner."

And therein lies the foundation for a legal tiff. According to Duncan
Edwards, corporate counsel for Outlast, "In terms of splitting and
understanding intellectual property, essentially Outlast has everything
in fibers and fabrics, and Frisby has foam. Their (Frisby's) new
non-woven product has been in development for two years, during the
very time we were negotiating the initial patent infringement.

"We feel that, in addition to the clear violation of our patent, we
were not being dealt with in good faith."

Duncan Russell, president and COO of Frisby disagrees:

"We have spent the better part of two years working jointly with the
world's largest and most respected non-woven manufacturer, Freudenberg,
to create a new intellectual property," he told SNEWS®. "We own the
material jointly, the pending worldwide patent jointly, and we will
defend it jointly and do not intend to deviate from that course.

"Obviously we would never bring to market something that we feel would
violate someone else's patent. At the same time, we do not believe that
they own the only existing technology using PCMs (phase-change
materials) and that there is certainly always a new way to do things.
And, perhaps that captures the very essence regarding the nature of
this dispute."

SNEWS®View:
While there are those in the outdoor and fitness world rolling their
eyes wondering if these two will ever really kiss and make up, it is
important to realize that this kind of behavior is nothing new in
technology realms. The more our industries begin to push the scientific
and technological boundaries, the more it is likely we will see a
representative increase in these kinds of legal skirmishes and, of
course, a corresponding increase in very happy lawyer fees.


Related

Avocet Sports Technology files patent infringement lawsuit against Suunto and Amer

Avocet Sports Technology and Vertical Instruments, both based in Northern California, filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California against Amer Sports and its subsidiary, Suunto USA, for alleged patent infringement. The lawsuit, filed on ...read more

Outlast purchases Frisby assets in bankruptcy auction

Outlast Technologies, Inc. acquired most of the remaining assets of Frisby Technologies for $455,000 in a bankruptcy court auction that closed May 18. The assets include various technology licenses, Frisby's Thermasorb trademarks, logos and associated website, Frisby's company ...read more

DuPont becomes equity partner of Outlast

DuPont Textiles and Interiors (DTI) and Outlast today announced that the two companies had formed an equity alliance partnership. As part of the agreement, DTI has acquired a minority interest in Outlast. Tim Dummer, the global business manager for DTI overseeing the ...read more

EK patent infringement lawsuit against Chisco takes a curious turn

On March 28, SNEWS® received a notification email from EK Ekcessories announcing the company had filed a lawsuit on March 18, 2005, in U.S. District Court for the District of Utah against Chisco Sports Accessories for alleged patent infringement of the company's utility and ...read more

Cocona Technology Inc. files trademark infringement lawsuit

Cocona Technology, Inc., the Boulder, Colorado inventor and marketer of innovative fabric technologies, has filed a trademark infringement lawsuit against Hoyu Textile Company of Taiwan. The lawsuit contends that Hoyu is trading on the goodwill of the Cocona® brand by the use of ...read more

WaldiesCrocs.jpg

Crocs wins appeal on patent infringement against Waldies, Dawgs

The U.S. International Trade Commission recently reversed its course on a patent infringement ruling, giving Crocs Inc. the possibility it might be able to block imports of competing Dawgs and Waldies foam clog footwear. In 2008, the trade commission in Washington, D.C., had ...read more

Did you hear?... Outlast reorganizes management and staff

In keeping with its technology -- that is, phase change material -- Outlast has decided it needs to phase in a company change of its own through reorganization of management and staff. According to CEO George Cattermole, some positions have been eliminated, some new ones created, ...read more

ClimbX_MadRock-2010-thumb.jpg

Did you hear?…Mad Rock files lawsuit against Climb X

Nelson Sports, parent company of Mad Rock, filed a trademark infringement lawsuit on Sept. 20 in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California against Climb X and Joe Garland.  The Mad Rock (madrockclimbing.com) lawsuit includes 12 complaints against Climb X ...read more

Royal Robbins® Joins Forces with Outlast Technologies, Inc.

January 17, 2006 – Boulder, CO. - Outlast Technologies, Inc. announces the launch of the new Royal Robbins® Jonathan Plaid shirt powered with Outlast, the original temperature-regulation technology. Royal Robbins®, a leading manufacturer of travel and outdoor apparel, has ...read more