Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition threatens to sue Trump

Trump's executive order reviewing monuments is a thinly veiled attack against Bears Ears, tribal leaders say.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

Leaders from the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition called Trump's national monument review a thinly veiled attack on the monument.

The Bears Ears Buttes in summertime.

The Bears Ears Buttes in summertime. // Photo: Tim Peterson

If President Donald Trump tries to rescind the protected status of Bears Ears National Monument, he’ll be hit with a lawsuit to the fullest extent possible, leaders from the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition said Wednesday morning, at a press conference in Washington, D.C.

The governments of the tribes in the Coalition all support the monument, said Carleton Bowekaty, co-chair of the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition and Pueblo of Zuni Tribal Councilman, in spite of disagreement from a few individuals who have been outspoken in the media.

Members of Utah’s congressional delegation, as well as Utah Gov. Gary Herbert, have repeatedly said that they do not support the monument designation largely because of opposition from Native Americans who live in San Juan County and the surrounding area, where former President Barack Obama designated 1.3 million acres.

“The Navajo Nation has a clear position on Bears Ears National Monument,” LoRenzo Bates, of the Navajo Nation Council, said. “As indicated, there is unanimous support. But by cherrypicking a few Navajo people from San Juan County, you are undermining… the position of the Navajo government.”

Each member of each tribe is free to express their own opinion, Bowekaty said. But individuals’ opinions do not represent the official positions of their tribal governments.

The monument is on sacred land, and the designation is vital to the protection of ancestral territory and history, leaders said Wednesday. But it’s about more than that. It’s also about trust and betrayal on behalf of the United States government.

“The Trump Administration says he will put America first,” said Robert Holden, deputy director of the National Congress of American Indians. “Today, we urge the administration to work with the first Americans, who have been here.”

Since George Washington made promises to Native Americans that he would protect their land and ways of life, Holden said, more than 100 treaties have been broken by the U.S. government. “This is the time to stand fast with these promises, to change the past. To go forward, to work with our people to help us protect and preserve our national resources.”

Shaun Chapoose, Ute Indian Tribe Business Committee Chairman, said they were hopeful when Zinke was sworn in as Secretary of the Interior, but he has yet to meet with tribal leaders despite repeated meeting requests. Instead, he has met with congressmen from the state of Utah.

“The way we’re going to fight,” Chapoose said, “is we’re going to go to court.”

Related

Bears Ears

Utah asks Trump to rescind Bears Ears NM, Patagonia pulls out of Outdoor Retailer

Patagonia announced early this morning that it would not be attending Outdoor Retailer Summer Market this year, or any future shows hosted in Utah, because of the state's opposition to Bears Ears National Monument and other public lands issues. On Friday, Utah Gov. Gary ...read more

utah protest 6

It’s official: Trump slashes Utah national monuments

“There are no words. It’s heartbreaking,” Ace Kvale, outdoor photographer, told SNEWS as he was leaving the Salt Lake City protest against President Trump’s controversial announcement to downsize both Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante. With much resistance but little ...read more

Patagonia launches virtual reality videos of Bears Ears

Patagonia has launched a series of 360-degree videos highlighting the beauty, history, and outdoor recreation opportunities of Bears Ears National Monument. The monument’s status—as well as the Antiquities Act, which allowed former President Barack Obama to designate it—is ...read more

Bears Ears National Monument

Bears Ears: Why not?

Bears Ears National Monument stands quiet. Sunbaked terracotta pillars hold sentinel like broken chess pieces over a sandy board. Wind stirs the pinyon pine, flicking drifts of sand at the feet of thousand-year-old petroglyphs. Waves of heat vibrate in the valleys, a soft pulse. ...read more

Bears Ears

Interior Sec. Zinke recommends shrinking Bears Ears National Monument

Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke says he spent days learning "more about Bears Ears than [he] ever thought possible." After taking a multi-day tour through the area, he announced Monday that he has recommended President Donald Trump shrink the boundaries of Bears Ears National ...read more

Craters of the Moon National Monument

Zinke to recommend downsizing some monuments

Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke is expected to recommend to President Donald Trump that he should decrease the boundaries of some national monuments. Zinke told the Associated Press Thursday morning that he would not recommend eliminating any monuments, and that none of the land in ...read more

Bears Ears National Monument

President Donald Trump Highway...In Utah?

Environmentalists are shaking their heads in disgust at the thought of having a Utah highway named after President Donald Trump, especially one that winds through canyons and by public lands that he shrunk last year with the stroke of his presidential pen. State legislators in a ...read more

courtesyoftimpeterson

Now is the time to protect Bears Ears

More than 50 years ago, when signing the groundbreaking Wilderness Act, President Lyndon Johnson said: “If future generations are to remember us with gratitude rather than contempt, we must leave them a glimpse of the world as it was in the beginning, not just after we got ...read more

Bears Ears Monument

Trump moves forward with a plan to shrink two national monuments

President Trump plans to move forward with a plan that will shrink the size of two national monuments in Utah, according to Utah Senator Orrin Hatch. The Senator said Trump informed him Friday via phone that he would be approve Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke’s recommendation to ...read more