Potential court review of rescission by Fitness Source franchisees may provide case law in Ontario

When executives of The Forzani Group received a franchise rescission from the Toronto-area Fitness Source franchisee, they were at first surprised. Second, Forzani attorneys said they realized, when checking into the relatively new franchise law in Ontario -- one of only four of Canada's 10 provinces with something similar -- there wasn't much case law to guide a resolution.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

When executives of The Forzani Group received a franchise rescission from the Toronto-area Fitness Source franchisee, they were at first surprised.

Second, Forzani attorneys said they realized, when checking into the relatively new franchise law in Ontario -- one of only four of Canada's 10 provinces with something similar -- there wasn't much case law to guide a resolution.

Forzani's in-house legal counsel Mathieu St. Charles told SNEWS® the Arthur Wishart Act of Ontario indicates that a franchisee may rescind a franchise agreement within two years, as stated in our April 6, 2009, story, "Fitness Source Toronto shuts down as Forzani steps back in as owner-operator." As a part of that rescission, franchisees may also claim losses and expect certain refunds of expenses.

However, the allowance of a rescission and subsequent refunds in the Wishart Act of 2000 is based on the allegation that a franchisor never issued a disclosure statement, issued one late, or did not issue one that is deemed complete. This is where the two sides seem to differ.

"In our opinion, the document was complete," St. Charles said.

Forzani, with 227 franchise stores under various banners as of Feb. 1, 2009, did not formally accept the rescission letter, St. Charles said, which a franchisor has the option to do. However, both the company and the franchisees agreed Forzani and its subsidiary Sports Experts 2000 would take back the stores and the stores would continue to operate as corporate stores once the transfer is complete.

The franchisees -- Mitchell Melnick, Frank Fallico and Peter Zambito -- who took on a franchise of the nine Toronto-area Fitness Sources stores in April 2007 and delivered the franchise rescission letter to Forzani offices in March 2009, have declined further comment to SNEWS about the matter.

Meanwhile, the Fitness Source stores in question were shut down on March 31 after inventory was completed. Forzani let go all employees since they were franchisee employees but the company is now working to rehire employees so it can quickly reopen the stores.

St. Charles declined to state how much per store the former franchisees had claimed in refunds or expenses. The Wishart franchise disclosure act describes required refunds of "any money received from or on behalf of the franchisee, other than money for inventory, supplies or equipment," as well as compensation "for any losses that the franchisee incurred in setting up and operating the franchise." In addition, the act states that franchisors must purchase back inventory as well as supplies and equipment "at a price equal to the purchase price paid by the franchisee."

Those refunds are to occur within 60 days, per the law, but St. Charles noted the company does not agree to the refunds.

"We didn't accept the rescission notice since we don't feel they have a right to do so," he told SNEWS, "and we are not prepared to accept the amount the franchisee is claiming."

He said Forzani and the franchisee have agreed to try to negotiate a resolution of their dispute out-of-court but, if unsuccessful, the court may end up reviewing the matter.

--Therese Iknoian

Related

FitnessSourceLogo.jpg

Forzani re-opens Toronto-area Fitness Source stores under corporate oversight

After suddenly shuttering its nine Fitness Source stores in the Toronto area in late March when its franchisees rescinded their operation agreement, Forzani has re-opened the stores as of May 1. According to Tom Quinn, Forzani president and COO, about 80 percent of the former ...read more

FitnessSourceLogo.jpg

Fitness Source Toronto shuts down as Forzani steps back in as owner-operator

Forzani has taken back control of the operations of the Toronto-area Fitness Source stores after the three men running the business for the last two years suddenly stepped out, SNEWS® has learned. A few days ago, SNEWS started hearing all Toronto-area Fitness Source stores ...read more

Canada's Fitness Source acquired by Forzani Group, expansion plotted

In an effort to branch further into the fitness arena, the Forzani Group has acquired the Fitness Source's nine retail locations in Ontario, Canada. Terms of the deal were not disclosed. "We are looking forward to building a strong national chain within the next 48 months," Tom ...read more

Will those confidentiality statements at the bottom of emails hold weight in a court of law?

We’ve all seen it at one time or another on the emails that come across our computer. A glaring warning statement that reads: “This message and any attachments are intended only for the use of the intended recipient, are confidential, and may be privileged.” Weighty words, but ...read more

Fitness 2004: SNEWS® reviews the year

From recalls to lawsuits, from retail changes to manufacturer acquisitions, 2004 has been quite a breathless year. The recalls hit some particularly hard (Nautilus, Fitness Quest and Horizon), and the legal wrangling provided continuing tennis-match, head-swiveling entertainment, ...read more

Forzani plans dozens of Fitness Source franchises with new retail/training concept

Originally discussed with SNEWS® 20 months ago, Forzani is now set to go forward with a concept for its specialty fitness stores, Fitness Source, which will include larger formats, a retail and personal training element and, eventually, several dozen stores across Canada. Tom ...read more

Fitness 2003: SNEWS reviews the year

It's been a long year -- perhaps longer for some companies than for others. With the stock market in a tumble, the few public companies in the fitness industry were mostly struggling to re-organize, re-structure and keep ahead of the tide. But that didn't stop legal squirmishes ...read more

Court dismisses Nautilus patent case against Icon

Already having knocked down wins in the last few court rounds, Icon Fitness took the TKO in the legal battle brought by Nautilus charging patent infringement on the Bowflex by Icon's Crossbow when the district court dismissed the case last week. "It's done, for all intents and ...read more

Law Review Quarterly Q1 2005 is out, packed with news that affects your business

The Law Review for the outdoor and fitness industries has just emailed its second official issue, and you don't want to miss out. There are reports that deal with cases that you need to know about since they could have an affect on the future health of your business. Don't know ...read more