Ocean Kayaks Wins One, Goes After Another

We reported in September 2000 about Ocean Kayak's suit against Watermark for patent infringement on its Malibu Two and Cabo sit-on-top kayaks.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

llllllooooooWe reported in September 2000 about Ocean Kayak's suit against Watermark for patent infringement on its Malibu Two and Cabo sit-on-top kayaks. Because of the pending suit, Watermark's Islander division did not show any of its Festiva kayaks at Outdoor Retailer Summer Market.

In December, an agreement was reached stipulating Watermark will no longer sell any multi-person sit-on-top kayak that has "foot wells that themselves overlap or allow the feet or legs of a person to overlap, a forward facing seat." OK, legalese but Ocean Kayak made its point.

But the company hasn't stopped there. It continues to press on patent infringement issues. On December 11, Ocean Kayak filed suit against California-based Glenwa, Inc. (Cobra Kayaks) for infringement of Ocean Kayak's U.S. Patent No. 5,964,177 and U.S. Patent No. 6,152,063. These patents are currently embodied in Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two and Cabo models. Ocean Kayak's federal court complaint asserts the Cobra Tandem is a copy of the Malibu Two model and infringes upon its patent. Ocean Kayak seeks damages and an injunction against further infringement.

"We are determined to defend Ocean Kayak's substantial investment in our patented products. We are confident that the federal court will grant us all of the relief we have requested," said Del McAlpine, Ocean Kayak's Controller.

A release from Ocean Kayak states: "Ocean Kayak believes that the rapid penetration of the Malibu Two into resorts and popular markets generated enormous pressure on other kayak companies to create a comparable product."

Ocean Kayak Director of Sales, Mark Harman, added in the release: "The unique features of the Malibu Two contributed to astronomical growth within the sit-on-top kayak industry. The overlapping foot wells are a special feature that lend to the versatility of the Malibu Two and Cabo models. In fact, we think this patented feature is so unique many competitors may be willing to risk infringement to save their place in the sit-on-top kayak market segment. This feature is definitely one of the primary contributors to the growth within the industry."

Related

Cobra claims victory, Ocean Kayak says no

After a two-year battle in the courts, Cobra Kayaks issued a press release claiming it had won a victory against Ocean Kayaks over the company's alleged infringement on patents pertaining to the Malibu II kayak seating designs held by Ocean and was "now free to go back to the ...read more

Federal Judge Rules In Favor Of Ocean Kayak Against Cobra

Ocean Kayak's relentless pursuit of those the company feels have infringed on its patents bore fruit earlier this week. In a judgment handed down in Federal District Court in Portland, Ore., it was deemed that as a matter of law Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two patent is valid. The Oct. ...read more

Federal Judge Rules In Favor Of Ocean Kayak Against Cobra

Ocean Kayak's relentless pursuit of those the company feels have infringed on its patents bore fruit earlier this week. In a judgment handed down in Federal District Court in Portland, Ore., it was deemed that as a matter of law Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two patent is valid. The Oct. ...read more

Cobra Kayak and Ocean Kayak, round two

Cobra Kayaks and Ocean Kayak are engaged in what might become one of the longest running legal ping-pong games we've witnessed in years. As you may recall only a few weeks ago, one District Court judge ruled that two Cobra Kayak models "indisputably infringe" upon an Ocean Kayak ...read more

Did you hear?... Cobra Kayaks and Ocean Kayak engaged in a legal ping-pong game

Cobra Kayaks and Ocean Kayak are engaged in what might become one of the longest running legal ping-pong games we've witnessed in years. As you may recall only a few weeks ago, one District Court judge ruled that two Cobra Kayak models "indisputably infringe" upon an Ocean Kayak ...read more

Ocean Kayak Celebrates 40th Anniversary

Ocean Kayak, the brand that helped pioneer the sit-on-top kayak category, celebrates its 40th anniversary in 2011. Since the brand's inception in 1971, Ocean Kayak has become synonymous with the stable, durable and paddler-friendly sit-on-top kayak and has subsequently emerged as ...read more

Nautilus vs. Icon infringement fisticuffs goes another round

Nautilus and Icon are now expected to go to jury trial later this year in the patent infringement case brought by Nautilus in December 2002 that charges the Crossbow infringes on the Bowflex. Although a district court last October dismissed the patent case brought by Nautilus ...read more

Glenwa wins big against Johnson, but…

A long-awaited March 19 ruling handed down by the Oregon Federal District Court in Johnson Outdoors' three-year-long patent infringement battle against Glenwa (Cobra Kayaks) found in favor of Glenwa on all counts. The Oregon court upheld a Jan. 14, 2003, ruling by the U.S. Court ...read more

Icon wins another round in Nautilus patent infringement battle

In a continuing volley in the legal battle over patent infringement, Icon Health & Fitness picked up another point when a district court last week granted the company a motion that means the court has found the Icon-made Crossbow machine is not substantially similar to the ...read more