Nautilus sues rival Icon over Bowflex patent violation claims - SNEWS

Nautilus sues rival Icon over Bowflex patent violation claims

The Nautilus Group has charged rival equipment maker Icon Health & Fitness with Bowflex patent infringement by Icon's Weider Crossbow machine, taking the complaint to court in a lawsuit filed last week.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

The Nautilus Group has charged rival equipment maker Icon Health & Fitness with Bowflex patent infringement by Icon's Weider Crossbow machine, taking the complaint to court in a lawsuit filed last week.

"We will absolutely defend our assets and patents as due course of our business," Nautilus President Kevin Lamar told SNEWS about the lawsuit after its filing.

The lawsuit, filed Dec. 3 in the U.S. District Court, Western District of Washington, claims the Logan, Utah-based, Icon company has violated two of Nautilus' patents in the Bowflex machine upon which the company, then known as Direct Focus, found its claim to fame and fortune.Â

The lawsuit charging Icon stole the technology states that the Crossbow incorporates structures corresponding to its patented Bowflex. It asks the court not only to hold Icon liable for infringing and to enjoin the company from further infringement, but also to award the Vancouver, Wash.-based, Nautilus (NYSE: NLS) damages incurred, as well as attorneys' fees, and that "damages be trebled in view of the willful and deliberate nature of the defendants' infringing conduct."

"This is merely an attempt to seek removal of a legal action we initiated against Nautilus Group this past September in Utah," said Brad Bearnson, Icon legal counsel, referring to a suit filled Aug. 30 in the Utah District Court. "The Utah action seeks a determination from the court that Icon products do not infringe the Nautilus Group patents or intellectual property.

"Nautilus chose not to respond to Icon's action until late November, and has now filed this action in an effort to seek removal of the action from Utah to Washington state," Bearnson added. "We are confident in our actions and will proceed on course."

In the Utah case filed Aug. 30, Icon lays out background that includes letters, allegations, patents, complaints and other claims that relate to its PowerFlex machine made for Gold's Gym, that equipment's advertisements (see SNEWS story on the PowerFlex from Nov. 4 for which Nautilus didn't answer phone calls or emails), plus Nautilus Group's claims about Bowflex construction and materials. In a legal answer by Nautilus to the court dated Nov. 13, Nautilus denied the claims and made counterclaims. On Dec. 6, a pre-trial conference was set for Jan. 22, 2003.

SNEWS View: Got all that? This feels a little like Who's on first, What's his name's on second, and I Don't Know's on third… and our heads are a-whirlin'. We have the pages of documents in front of us and are scratching our heads over the claims, allegations, letters and counterclaims, trying to make sense of them. We will. We promise. And we'll tell you about it when we do. Meanwhile, the bottom line? The Aug. 30 Icon suit against Nautilus, followed by the counter complaints by Nautilus Nov. 13, followed by this lawsuit by Nautilus against Icon on Dec. 3 are really good examples of making attorneys very happy.

Related

Nautilus loses preliminary injunction in Icon lawsuit

Losing the first round court battle in its lawsuit charging Icon with infringement of its Bowflex patents, The Nautilus Group will appeal a court ruling that denied a preliminary injunction it sought against Icon Health & Fitness. The injunction would have halted Icon's Weider ...read more

Court dismisses Nautilus patent case against Icon

Already having knocked down wins in the last few court rounds, Icon Fitness took the TKO in the legal battle brought by Nautilus charging patent infringement on the Bowflex by Icon's Crossbow when the district court dismissed the case last week. "It's done, for all intents and ...read more

Nautilus sues Icon again, this time over "CrossBar" name

Once again, Nautilus and Icon are preparing to cross paths in the courtroom. On July 21, the Nautilus Group (NYSE: NLS), manufacturer of the Bowflex, filed a second trademark infringement lawsuit against Icon Health & Fitness to prevent Icon from using the name CrossBar on ...read more

Icon wins another round in Nautilus patent infringement battle

In a continuing volley in the legal battle over patent infringement, Icon Health & Fitness picked up another point when a district court last week granted the company a motion that means the court has found the Icon-made Crossbow machine is not substantially similar to the ...read more

Icon wins first court-ordered payment from Nautilus in Bowflex patent case

Chipping away at the nearly $8 million verdict against Nautilus stemming from a 2002 trademark and patent infringement case, a federal judge has ruled that Nautilus must pay Icon $325,000 for false advertising of its Bowflex. The fine is part of a larger penalty awarded by a ...read more

Nautilus vs. Icon infringement claims: The beat goes on

On the heels of the federal court ruling earlier this month that said the district court needed to reconsider the evidence that had led it to recent rulings in Icon's favor, the Bowflex patent infringement case filed by Nautilus against Icon more than 16 months ago will go ...read more

U.S. court dismisses Nautilus' patent infringement case against Icon

After racking up a majority of the legal wins in the past, Nautilus came up short this week when a U.S. court dismissed all remaining claims in its pending patent infringement case against Icon less a month before charges were to go to trial, effectively ending the case. The ...read more

Nautilus vs. Icon infringement fisticuffs goes another round

Nautilus and Icon are now expected to go to jury trial later this year in the patent infringement case brought by Nautilus in December 2002 that charges the Crossbow infringes on the Bowflex. Although a district court last October dismissed the patent case brought by Nautilus ...read more

Icon sues Octane for patent infringement in California… and names one retailer: four-store Nellie's

In a lawsuit that charges Octane Fitness with patent infringement, Icon Health & Fitness has included one retailer -- four-store Southern California retailer Nellie's -- in the case that names patent violations on one elliptical. So far, the suit only generally names two of ...read more