Mammut Besal Jacket


A year ago, a "waterproof soft shell" would have been considered an oxymoron to most people. After all, a soft shell is supposed to trade off rain protection for better breathability -- or so a number of ardent soft shell proponents have argued. But the new Mammut Besal Jacket ($375) clearly defies the paradigm.

This is a true climbing shell made for wet, winter activities. As you'd expect from a soft shell, the fabric has four-way stretch for freedom of movement and a fuzzy Coolmax inner surface for moisture wicking, comfort and a touch of warmth. The cut of the jacket is on the trim, athletic side too so there is no flapping in the wind or excess bulk restricting vision when climbing.

But unlike most soft shells, the Schoeller three-layer fabric has a waterproof/breathable laminate and all the seams are taped. So even in wet snow or drizzle, and when climbing on dripping ice climbs, the Besal keeps you dry. While most of the top-end soft shells have a good DWR, they just can't offer this level of protection.

In the cool to cold weather for which the Besal is designed, the fabric breathes reasonably well. When the heart-rate climbs and sweat starts to pour, venting chest pockets and pit zippers (all with water-resistant zippers) offer much-needed additional ventilation. The jacket does get somewhat odiferous after a good bout of sweating, however. The fuzzy lining does make the Besal slightly harder to pull over a fleece jacket, but this is also true of many soft shells.

As you would expect, the jacket has a good hood that will fit over a helmet; drawcords have sleeves so they won't whap you in the face. There is no waist drawcord to create pressure points under a pack's hipbelt, just elastic in the hem. Inside, a large mesh pocket and a smaller one for sunglasses provides adequate storage.

At 32 ounces (910 grams) for a size large, the Besal jacket isn't lightweight but it is extremely rugged; shoulder areas use Keprotec laminate for maximum durability. Yet compared to the typical beefy hard shell in the same weight range, this is trimmer and has far better freedom of movement.

So once again, advancing technology forces users to rethink their clothing system and question the need for traditional hard shells even more. Hopefully, Mammut will explain the technology to consumers -- a very weak area for many European manufacturers. As the first waterproof soft shell (more are on the way from other brands), the Besal Jacket increases the options but it's not the end-all piece since it remains too warm and heavy for some places and times of year. Serious alpine climbers and backcountry skiers are going to dig it though.

SNEWS Rating: 4 hands clapping (1 to 5 hands clapping possible, with 5 clapping hands representing functional and design perfection)

Suggested retail: $375

For more information:




Mountain Hardwear Synchro Jacket

Gack, not another soft shell review! We've tried virtually every permutation of this category since it first emerged in 1986 and are as tired of the hoopla as anybody. But the new Mountain Hardwear Synchro Jacket caught our attention since it claims to be “extremely durable, more


NRS Stampede Paddle Jacket

There are plenty of paddling jackets on the market and many borrow features from one another so there isn’t much that obviously differentiates them at first glance. The latest generation of the NRS Stampede separates itself from the field by becoming the first, and so far only, more


Isis for Women Sophia Jacket

Sure, the Sophia soft shell jacket has got all the technical bells and whistles you'll want, but it also looks so dang good that you'll get compliments and stand taller wearing it. Our tester has literally turned heads walking into a room (granted, one full of tech-head more


GoLite Kinetic Jacket

With a name like Kinetic, you gotta know this jacket is built for moving and moving fast. And so it is, from its fabric to its design. You just want to get moving from the moment you put it on. In fact, even if you aren't moving, you just feel fast. The jacket has ultra more


Patagonia Dragonfly Full-zip Jacket

It took a couple of years to refine things but the Dragonfly concept has finally achieved near perfection. The new Dragonfly Full-zip Jacket is simultaneously sophisticated yet simple, versatile yet unobtrusive. Made entirely of 1.1-ounce triple ripstop nylon fabric with a good more


Mountain Hardwear Phantom Jacket

For cold belays when it appears your climbing partner is going to be awhile or for those late fall or early winter evenings around the camp or cabin when a fleece just isn't enough to ward off the chill, there's nothing better than slipping on a cozy down jacket. Trouble is, more


Lole Avenue Jacket

Targeted to inherently feminine, active women who love the outdoors, Lole is a Montreal-based brand that launched its line of style-driven women’s activewear in 2002. Recently, SNEWS took out Lole’s new Avenue jacket (pictured below) for a test run. It is a three-quarter more


The North Face Kishtwar jacket

Ever since soft shell garments were introduced, people have struggled to define the category, though it’s generally agreed that soft shells are typically water-resistant, somewhat soft to the touch, highly breathable, and relatively stretchy. Because soft shells are so more


Marmot Reyna jacket

As winter tried to hang onto its last bits of wind and snow in some parts of the country, the SNEWS® editors took Marmot's Reyna women's jacket out into some of the elements. Part of the company's M1 series, the soft shell jacket is made of Polartec Windbloc fabric made for more