Federal Judge Rules In Favor Of Ocean Kayak Against Cobra

Ocean Kayak's relentless pursuit of those the company feels have infringed on its patents bore fruit earlier this week. In a judgment handed down in Federal District Court in Portland, Ore., it was deemed that as a matter of law Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two patent is valid. The Oct. 4 summary judgment found Cobra Kayak's Tandem, Triple, and Fish 'n Dive models to all "indisputably infringe" upon Ocean Kayak's patents. As a result, Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two, Ocean Kayak Cabo, and Aegean are currently the only tandem kayaks on the market with patented seating and hull design that allows a flexible seating arrangement -- for one, two, or two and a small passenger -- in a portable, compact design.
Author:
Publish date:

Ocean Kayak's relentless pursuit of those the company feels have infringed on its patents bore fruit earlier this week. In a judgment handed down in Federal District Court in Portland, Ore., it was deemed that as a matter of law Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two patent is valid. The Oct. 4 summary judgment found Cobra Kayak's Tandem, Triple, and Fish 'n Dive models to all "indisputably infringe" upon Ocean Kayak's patents. As a result, Ocean Kayak's Malibu Two, Ocean Kayak Cabo, and Aegean are currently the only tandem kayaks on the market with patented seating and hull design that allows a flexible seating arrangement -- for one, two, or two and a small passenger -- in a portable, compact design.

The Court ruling means that Ocean Kayak has exclusive rights to manufacture and sell tandem sit-on-tops with center seat and overlapping foot well features. Any other company that designs or sells a kayak using these features infringes on Ocean Kayak’s rights under U.S. patent law.

Del McAlpine, Ocean Kayak's controller, stated, "This process has been long, and our competitors have misrepresented the validity of our patent. We are thrilled with Judge Ancer Haggerty's decision."

McAlpine also told SNEWS®, "There are still a couple of other cases pending that we are pursuing." He added, "We will vigorously continue to go after all who infringe on our patents."

A trial to determine appropriate damages will be conducted on Nov. 6, 2001. The sole issue will be the amount owed by Glenwa (Cobra Kayaks) to Ocean Kayak for infringing on Ocean Kayak’s patents.

Related

Cobra claims victory, Ocean Kayak says no

After a two-year battle in the courts, Cobra Kayaks issued a press release claiming it had won a victory against Ocean Kayaks over the company's alleged infringement on patents pertaining to the Malibu II kayak seating designs held by Ocean and was "now free to go back to the ...read more

Ocean Kayaks Wins One, Goes After Another

llllllooooooWe reported in September 2000 about Ocean Kayak's suit against Watermark for patent infringement on its Malibu Two and Cabo sit-on-top kayaks. Because of the pending suit, Watermark's Islander division did not show any of its Festiva kayaks at Outdoor Retailer Summer ...read more

Cobra Kayak and Ocean Kayak, round two

Cobra Kayaks and Ocean Kayak are engaged in what might become one of the longest running legal ping-pong games we've witnessed in years. As you may recall only a few weeks ago, one District Court judge ruled that two Cobra Kayak models "indisputably infringe" upon an Ocean Kayak ...read more

Glenwa wins big against Johnson, but…

A long-awaited March 19 ruling handed down by the Oregon Federal District Court in Johnson Outdoors' three-year-long patent infringement battle against Glenwa (Cobra Kayaks) found in favor of Glenwa on all counts. The Oregon court upheld a Jan. 14, 2003, ruling by the U.S. Court ...read more