Colassi expresses relief over end of litigation with Cybex after 12 years

When a federal appeals court declined to re-hear Cybex's losing appeal on the nearly 12-year-old patent infringement battle brought by Gary Colassi, it closed the book on the case, leaving Colassi relieved he could move on.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

When a federal appeals court declined to re-hear Cybex's losing appeal on the nearly 12-year-old patent infringement battle brought by Gary Colassi, it closed the book on the case, leaving Colassi relieved he could move on.

"We got the win, and I'm really relieved it's finally over with," Colassi told SNEWS®. "The little guy has prevailed."

Cybex (NYSE: CYB) had originally appealed the 2005 judgment against it by the U.S. District Court, District of Massachusetts, to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The federal court affirmed the lower court's ruling in February 2007, and Cybex requested a re-hearing on the appeal, which was ultimately denied.

"While we are disappointed that the court denied our request for a re-hearing, we are pleased that, with the finalization of this suit, we have no further non-insured open litigation matters," said Cybex CEO John Aglialoro in a statement.

The company added that it would not further pursue the case and would make its payment to Colassi of the $2.5 million judgment plus interest in the next 30 days. Damages were based on a "reasonable royalty" on the treadmills sold since the patent filing, the 2005 lower-court verdict stated.

Colassi, who has run a World Gym in Foxboro, Mass., for 18 years, said he first contacted Medway, Mass.-based, Cybex about his idea and with drawings of a cushioned system for treadmill decks in December 1995. He applied for the patent in 1996 and it was granted to him in September 2000. When Cybex later came out with the "Stableflex" cushioned deck on its own -- after it had reviewed his designs for several months, then declined to license the concept -- Colassi claimed infringement and filed suit in September 2002.

"This is my art," Colassi said. "This is what I did. I created it, and it killed me this company was in denial."

Aside from relief, though, he also expressed disappointment that the case ended up in the courts and taking such huge legal fees from both sides -- money that could have been better spent elsewhere.

"It's been a shame the company had to take this route," he said. "The attorneys' fees are astronomical, and that's the shame of it all…. It's going to be a big lawyer bill."

The judgment had been previously reserved on Cybex's consolidated financial statements, and the company reported it did not anticipate its payment would result in any further charge to earnings.

SNEWS® View: Yet another matter that seems to get wrapped up in the legal system, doing nothing ultimately except fattening the pocketbooks of leagues of attorneys. In this case, between Cybex and Colassi's attorneys, we're talking expenses that were much, much more than the final verdict. That's simply a pity.

Related

CybexLogo.jpg

Cybex 3Q sales up, but slight losses continue on litigation appeal

Cybex International, Inc. (NASDAQ: CYBI) continued its 2011 upward earnings trend by reporting another quarter of higher revenue, but it faced a second-straight quarter of slightly wider losses as it continues to incur costs while appealing an unfavorable lawsuit ruling. The ...read more

Fitness financial: Cybex litigation charge creates 3Q operating income loss

Despite showing sales growth in the third quarter and nine months ended Sept. 24, 2005, of 7 percent, Cybex had to satisfy itself with a reported loss in operating income of $2.830 million due to a litigation charge of $4.1 million. Without the charge, the company would have ...read more

Judge affirms Cybex vs. Kirila ruling…two years later

More than two years after a jury verdict that awarded former Pyramid Fitness owner Gene Kirila $900,000-plus in damages from Cybex International, the judge in the case has affirmed the verdict -- and added some $1.5 million in interest, attorneys' fees and penalties. According ...read more

Nautilus loses federal appeal of Icon victory in patent infringement case

Icon's legal victory in a patent infringement case brought against it by Nautilus nearly four years ago was affirmed by the federal court when that court declined to hear the ruling by the lower court. On Aug. 21, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington, ...read more

CybexLogo.jpg

Cybex receives delisting notice as it readies to appeal $66 million jury verdict

Cybex International has received a mandatory notice from the Nasdaq exchange where it trades (CYB), noting it has fallen below the standards to remain listed. The stock price has sunk below the Nasdaq’s minimum of $1 for 30 consecutive days -- a plunge taken immediately following ...read more

PanIP LLC continues with e-tail litigation filings

PanIP LLC, a San Diego, Calif.-based, corporation, has filed 40 more suits in U.S. District Court, alleging that each of the small businesses served with a complaint have infringed upon the e-commerce patents of Lawrence Lockwood -- also coincidently a principal of PanIP LLC. ...read more

Simonson joins Cybex in exclusive multi-year product development deal

Lauded industrywide as an equipment inventor that knows how to think outside the box, Roy Simonson will join forces with Cybex in an exclusive multi-year deal for product development, design and marketing. The agreement was announced nearly two years to the day that a two-year ...read more

CybexLogo.jpg

Jury verdict against Cybex reduced to $44 million

A New York appeals court has reduced a near $66 million jury verdict faced by fitness equipment manufacturer Cybex to $44 million. The ruling by the Appellate Division, Fourth Judicial Department, of the Supreme Court of the State of New York in the case of Natalie Barnhard vs. ...read more

CybexLogo.jpg

Cybex swings to 1Q profit, continues lawsuit appeal

Cybex International Inc. (Nasdaq: CYBI) continues to recover from the effects of a down economy and recent unfavorable judgment from a liability lawsuit as it reported higher revenue and swung to a profit for the first quarter. The Medway, Mass.-based fitness equipment ...read more